home for the holidays

Remember when Christmas shopping was part of the fun?

An afternoon downtown. Christmas carols playing. Finding something you couldn't wait to give.

Welcome to Neighbors.

We've reimagined the town's beloved hardware store as a welcoming general store with two floors full of thoughtful gifts, home goods, outdoor gear, Christmas décor, toys, and kitchen favorites.

Bring your list. Take your time. Enjoy a little of the Christmas you remember.

Visit Neighbors This Christmas

Plan Your Holiday Visit Shop Christmas Finds

Inside Neighbors Mercantile in downtown Nappanee

Your Neighbors in Nappanee

Where Neighbors Feel Like Family

We know what it's like to want something real. Neighbors Mercantile is a family-owned general store in downtown Nappanee, stocked with the things our own staff use at home, from kitchen and décor to outdoor gear, toys, and gifts.

Family Owned

A local business, right on Market Street.

Staff Favorites

Products we actually use in our own homes.

Fair Prices

Trusted brands and unexpected bargains.

Friendly Service

Help for any size order, big or small.

Wall Art

The Art of Cozy

Bring a little warmth to your walls with art made for the season.

Explore Prints

A Little Christmas Shopping.A Whole Day Together.

Take a drive through Amish country and spend a relaxed day exploring Neighbors Mercantile in downtown Nappanee. Browse holiday décor, home favorites, and gifts for every age—from toys and outdoor gear to practical finds and a few good bargains. Bring a friend, take your time, and leave with treasures you didn't know you were looking for.

Get Directions