Toys
Home
/
Store
/
Featured Products
/
Christmas
/
Toys
Refine by
Sort by
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
Filters
Clear all
Filters
Clear all
Show items
Show items
Again Friends Sprouts Penguin
Again Friends Sprouts Penguin
$15.98
Add to Bag
Again Friends Sprouts Reindeer
Again Friends Sprouts Reindeer
$15.98
Add to Bag
Again Friends Sprouts Snowman
Again Friends Sprouts Snowman
$15.98
Add to Bag
Arctic Blue Putty Penguin
Arctic Blue Putty Penguin
$17.98
Add to Bag
Bundle Up Putty Teddy
Bundle Up Putty Teddy
$29.98
Add to Bag
Charlie Brown Christmas Story Box
Charlie Brown Christmas Story Box
$29.98
Add to Bag
Christmas Tube
Christmas Tube
$12.48
Add to Bag
Christmas Warmies
Christmas Warmies
$29.98
Add to Bag
Clarice with Scarf Warmie
Clarice with Scarf Warmie
$34.98
Add to Bag
Cookies for Santa Play Set
Cookies for Santa Play Set
$14.98
Add to Bag
Dasher Putty Dachshund
Dasher Putty Dachshund
$17.98
Add to Bag
Dusky Putty Husky
Dusky Putty Husky
$24.98
Add to Bag
Friends Advent Calendar LEGO
Friends Advent Calendar LEGO
$34.99
Add to Bag
Gingerbread Man Wind Up
Gingerbread Man Wind Up
$3.48
Add to Bag
Holiday Capybara Warmie
Holiday Capybara Warmie
$29.98
Add to Bag
Jesus Is Born BibleBox Nativity Set
Jesus Is Born BibleBox Nativity Set
$23.98
Add to Bag
Knit Stuffed Sitting Fox 22”
Knit Stuffed Sitting Fox 22”
$17.98
Add to Bag
Marshmallow Junior Nutmeg Highland Cow
Marshmallow Junior Nutmeg Highland Cow
$17.98
Add to Bag
Marshmallow Tartan Terrier
Marshmallow Tartan Terrier
$25.98
Add to Bag
Nativity Wood Toy Set
Nativity Wood Toy Set
$19.98
Add to Bag
Putty Let It Snow Snowman
Putty Let It Snow Snowman
$24.98
Add to Bag
Rudolph with Scarf Warmie
Rudolph with Scarf Warmie
$34.98
Add to Bag
Sitting Santa Bear 11.5”
Sitting Santa Bear 11.5”
$20.98
Add to Bag
Skiing Snowman Wind Up
Skiing Snowman Wind Up
$3.48
Add to Bag
Snickerdoodle Putty Reindeer
Snickerdoodle Putty Reindeer
$17.98
Add to Bag
Soft Stuffed Penguin 11.75”
Soft Stuffed Penguin 11.75”
$26.98
Add to Bag
The Shepherd on the Search - Camel Plush
The Shepherd on the Search - Camel Plush
$14.98
Add to Bag
Ugly Sweater 4" Thinking Putty
Ugly Sweater 4" Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Skip to main content
Thanks for shopping with Neighbors this Season 🤍
Browse Holiday Arrivals
Menu
Gift Registry
Holiday
Apparel
Books, Games, & Puzzles
Hearth & Home
Local Merch
Outdoors
Toys
Gift Card
About Us
Blog
