Putty & Play Dough
Home
/
Store
/
Toys
/
Putty & Play Dough
Refine by
Sort by
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
Filters
Clear all
Filters
Clear all
Show items
Show items
Acai Bowl 2” Mini Thinking Putty
Acai Bowl 2” Mini Thinking Putty
$3.98
Add to Bag
Bounce Bot 2" Mini Tin
Bounce Bot 2" Mini Tin
$3.98
Add to Bag
Bubblegum / Marshmallow Scentsory Duos Putty
Bubblegum / Marshmallow Scentsory Duos Putty
$6.98
Add to Bag
Cereal O Clock Slime Charmers
Cereal O Clock Slime Charmers
$10.98
Add to Bag
Comic Book 4" Thinking Putty
Comic Book 4" Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Cosmic Matter Slime Charmers
Cosmic Matter Slime Charmers
$10.98
Add to Bag
Cotton Candy 2” Mini Thinking Putty
Cotton Candy 2” Mini Thinking Putty
$3.98
Add to Bag
Crisp Apple Putty
Crisp Apple Putty
$6.98
Add to Bag
Dolphin Dance 4” Thinking Putty
Dolphin Dance 4” Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Easy Squeeze Stretchy Pickle
Easy Squeeze Stretchy Pickle
$10.48
Add to Bag
Eggcellent 4” Thinking Putty
Eggcellent 4” Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Enchanting Unicorn 4" Thinking Putty
Enchanting Unicorn 4" Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Falling Water 4" Thinking Putty
Falling Water 4" Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Flower Power Vibes Scentsory Putty Tin
Flower Power Vibes Scentsory Putty Tin
$6.98
Add to Bag
Full Size 4" Putty Dolphin Dance
Full Size 4" Putty Dolphin Dance
$13.98
Add to Bag
Full Size 4" Thinking Putty
Full Size 4" Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Futbol 2” Mini Thinking Putty
Futbol 2” Mini Thinking Putty
$3.98
Add to Bag
Great Grape
Great Grape
$6.98
Add to Bag
Happy Earth 4" Magnetic Thinking Putty
Happy Earth 4" Magnetic Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Happy Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
Happy Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
$14.98
Add to Bag
Honey Hive 4" Thinking Putty
Honey Hive 4" Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
I Scream, You Scream Slime Charmers
I Scream, You Scream Slime Charmers
$10.98
Add to Bag
Jam Session Vibes Scentsory Putty Tin
Jam Session Vibes Scentsory Putty Tin
$6.98
Add to Bag
Ketchup and Mustard 2” Mini Thinking Putty
Ketchup and Mustard 2” Mini Thinking Putty
$3.98
Add to Bag
Liquid Glass 4" Thinking Putty
Liquid Glass 4" Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Loot Box Trend 2” Mini Thinking Putty
Loot Box Trend 2” Mini Thinking Putty
$3.98
Add to Bag
McSlime Slime Charmers
McSlime Slime Charmers
$10.98
Add to Bag
Melon Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
Melon Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
$14.98
Add to Bag
Mermaid Magic Slime Charmers
Mermaid Magic Slime Charmers
$10.98
Add to Bag
Mermaid Tale 4" Thinking Putty
Mermaid Tale 4" Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Mini Mini Mart Slime Charmers
Mini Mini Mart Slime Charmers
$10.98
Add to Bag
Mixed Emotions 4" Thinking Putty
Mixed Emotions 4" Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Ninja 4” Thinking Putty
Ninja 4” Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Ocean Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
Ocean Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
$14.98
Add to Bag
Orangesicle Putty
Orangesicle Putty
$6.98
Add to Bag
Owl 2” Mini Thinking Putty
Owl 2” Mini Thinking Putty
$3.98
Add to Bag
Pea Pod Mega 1 LB Thinking Putty
Pea Pod Mega 1 LB Thinking Putty
$34.98
Add to Bag
Pickleball 2” Mini Thinking Putty
Pickleball 2” Mini Thinking Putty
$3.98
Add to Bag
Rainbow Reveal 4” Thinking Putty
Rainbow Reveal 4” Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Relief Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
Relief Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
$14.98
Add to Bag
Scoopberry
Scoopberry
$6.98
Add to Bag
Shark 2” Mini Thinking Putty
Shark 2” Mini Thinking Putty
$3.98
Add to Bag
Snow Cone Scentsory Putty
Snow Cone Scentsory Putty
$6.98
Add to Bag
Starfish 2” Mini Thinking Putty
Starfish 2” Mini Thinking Putty
$3.98
Add to Bag
Strawberry Shortcake 4" Thinking Putty
Strawberry Shortcake 4" Thinking Putty
$13.98
Add to Bag
Sunny Side Up Slime Charmers
Sunny Side Up Slime Charmers
$10.98
Add to Bag
Super Scarab
Super Scarab
$13.98
Add to Bag
Sushi 2” Mini Thinking Putty
Sushi 2” Mini Thinking Putty
$3.98
Add to Bag
Sweet Surprise
Sweet Surprise
$13.98
Add to Bag
Tidal Wave
Tidal Wave
$13.98
Add to Bag
Triceratops 2” Mini Thinking Putty
Triceratops 2” Mini Thinking Putty
$3.98
Add to Bag
Tropical Punch
Tropical Punch
$6.98
Add to Bag
Unicorn Poop
Unicorn Poop
$5.98
Add to Bag
Very Cherry
Very Cherry
$6.98
Add to Bag
Watermelon Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
Watermelon Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
$14.98
Add to Bag
Zen Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
Zen Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
$14.98
Add to Bag
Skip to main content
Thanks for shopping with Neighbors this Season 🤍
Browse Holiday Arrivals
Menu
Gift Registry
Holiday
Apparel
Books, Games, & Puzzles
Hearth & Home
Local Merch
Outdoors
Toys
Gift Card
About Us
Blog
